Sponsor

To submit or not to submit… that is the question

In General Questions · 16 replies

To submit or not to submit… that is the question

Home › Forums › General Questions › To submit or not to submit… that is the question

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #7780
    Musicmatters
    Participant

    Greetings… fellow composers. I was wondering if any of you are caught up in the same dilemma….It seems so easy to keep submitting songs to multiple libraries and get carried away in the hope of extra income… on the other hand you ask yourself if you are devaluing your own music by doing so. There are many that will only submit a song to only one library and treat  exclusive the same as non exclusive. There are some that have the same track in as many libraries as possible.  I would love your comments… peace

Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #7805
    Musicmatters
    Participant

    Michael,

    I couldn’t agree more with “A”… thanks for your voice and posting with so much thought and consideration for us less experienced composers… it gives us a better roadmap. I, for one have been at this for the last couple of years… i am nowhere near meeting my expenses but i am ready to do whatever it takes and cannot imagine doing anything else. I also totally agree with the others that you have to write music whenever you can, and dont keep very high expectations… just let it come out. The more you do it the better you get and the better you know your tools and.. keep smiling…. peace to all

     

    Abbas

    #7803
    MichaelL
    Participant

    @Advice, thanks for the kind words. I’m no guru. I’ve been very very lucky.

    This is a brutal business that requires a lot of time and investment. There were four factors that I considered when I made the risky decision to leave my law practice and return to composing.

    1) I had already earned a living as a composer for 20 + years, 2) I was already earning royalties from 4 TV theme songs, 3) we had another source of income, and 4) I had saved 20 years worth of midi files (about 2,000) from which I could build a new catalog.

    If I had to start over from square one, without any one of those factors, I’d still be practicing law, despite my love of music and composing.

    As far as exclusives go, I’m used to getting paid upfront. In the 90’s I was making around mid five figures to produce 10-15 cues per month, including 5 versions of each cue: full, bed, 60, 30 and 15. I look back at that as library boot camp.

    So, I’m not really comfortable just handing cues over for free, particularly when there’s sometimes marginal difference between the backend payout for 15-30 seconds of music on a TV show and what the net would be on a sale of the same cue in a RF library. Case in point :38  of BG music in one of my shows on FOX paid $10.27. I just sold a :30 RF cue and netted $20. So, the RF cue is ahead by $9.73. Plus, that same RF cue has sold twice now.

    But…there’s always a but, this business is highly nuanced. There’s no single path to success. I spent 20+ years composing for corporate clients, technical films/videos and educational productions, non-broadcast producers…the heart of the RF client base. As such, the vast majority of the 2,000 cues that I’ve accumulated will go into RF libraries. Libraries like JP and Crucial don’t have much need for music that was composed for a manufacturing sequence in a corporate film, or for horseshoe crabs mating in a science documentary. So, I’m building on my strengths and experience.

    All libraries are not the same. You have to be a student of this business. You really have to do your homework and understand the libraries that you want to work with, what they need, and what they expect, who their clients are.  Otherwise, you are just shooting in the dark.

    Notice that I didn’t mention writing “MY” music, or “MY” vision, or “MY” art? There are places for that if you’re an indie artist or avant-garde composer, but generally speaking outside the realm of production music.

    You can learn a lot from composers who post here. Mark Petrie has offered tons of great advice, like “write every day, even when you don’t feel like it.” He also laid out his strategy of building on his back catalog, 12 hours a day, 6 days per week for 3 0r 4 years to get to the point of earning a living, with about (if I recall correctly) 1,500 tracks.

    Steven Baird once laid out his approach, which included minimizing his living expenses, which I think is very important. I think Steve said he had been at it for 3-4 years, and was approaching the point of being able to leave his day job, with about 500 tracks.

    In addition to being excellent writers, Mark and Steve have one thing in common…they understand business. That is so very very important.

    As Art says YMMV. What your needs are, and how you define “earning a living” are huge factors. My recollection is that at the end of 3-4 years Mark was making about twice what Steve projected that he would make 100K/50K, respectively.

    Minimizing your expenses, as Steven did,  helps you get there sooner. Hence, my wife and I are downsizing, de-blinging, and moving to the country. We all come from a different place. If you have kids or a mortgage, it’s not so easy.

    To address your question: Do I think that part-timers should give up and throw in the towel? NO. But…they need to be realistic. The day you get that first placement, is not the day to tell your boss what you really think of him or her. If you’re having fun and not losing your shirt, go for it.

    Enough rambling on. I’ll never get those tracks done, if I keep doing this.

    Cheers,

    Michael

     

    #7800
    Advice
    Participant

    One could make the argument that if you are not prolific, you shouldn’t be in this game. Not a very nice thing to hear if you only write a handful of tracks per year (like me!), but every industry has qualities one must have to truly succeed.

     

    Sorry, but that is an absolutely viable argument, and a very realistic one. We’ve done the math. It takes hundreds, if not thousands, of tracks to earn a living at this. Y0u are 100% correct. Every industry has “qualities one must have to truly succeed, ” or perhaps requirements. In law and medicine you must have degrees and pass bar exams and boards. Plumbers and electricians must be licensed. While there are no such formal requirements for success in this business, there are unwritten rules and harsh realities.

    Michael

    Just wanted so first say how much I enjoy your posts. You are always a voice of reason and experience and do a great job of informing and educating fellow composers. 🙂 Much appreciated!

    I agree with your response completely. As you know, I was pointing out that being afraid to sign exclusives often goes hand in hand with not writing enough tracks such that you can sign a bunch, let ’em go, and just write some more.

    As far as being in the game, not everyone has the goal of making a full time living at this. Some would like to earn some supplementary bucks, get pleasure and enjoyment out of seeing their music used in film/TV, etc. But yes, less tracks in the market, less chance regardless of what the goal is. And some of us who are not true f/t pros may be “weeded out” (for lack of a better term) as the industry shakes out, returns to primarily exclusive (except maybe so called “lower end” RF opps), etc. (I know some folks make lots of money in RF but they have a lot of tracks to begin with)…

    BTW, one way to increase your output and quality is to network more with other songwriters and composers and collaborate. That’s what I do more of now and the resulting tracks generally get put it only one library, especially when the library is a really good one.

    Thanks again, Michael!

    😀 A

    #7799
    Kenny
    Participant

    Thanx Art. This is pretty much the same way I do it. Making different titles to the various level of pricing of the libraries. I also use a couple of pseudonyms to avoid price shopping. But I`m not sure if this is necessary or if it`s the best way to do it, so it`s always helpful to hear how other composers deal with this.

    #7798
    Art Munson
    Keymaster

    Do you use a new title and a new pseudonym for each library you submit the song to

    I use one title for mid level RF libraries, another for higher priced RF libraries and another for the TV placement type (and my own) libraries. I have a database that keeps track of it all. Keep em guessing!

    No pseudonym though.

    #7797
    MichaelL
    Participant

    I’d be inclined to say that for tracks in RF libraries whereby the sale depends on end users coming to the site and finding your track, it MIGHT be less risky to be in multiple ones (though you are still competing with yourself and watering down the market).

    Not a problem IF you retain the publishing and DO NOT retile. Then, it actually doesn’t matter which RF library the music came from.

    One could make the argument that if you are not prolific, you shouldn’t be in this game. Not a very nice thing to hear if you only write a handful of tracks per year (like me!), but every industry has qualities one must have to truly succeed.

    Sorry, but that is an absolutely viable argument, and a very realistic one. We’ve done the math. It takes hundreds, if not thousands, of tracks to earn a living at this. Y0u are 100% correct. Every industry has “qualities one must have to truly succeed, ” or perhaps requirements. In law and medicine you must have degrees and pass bar exams and boards. Plumbers and electricians must be licensed. While there are no such formal requirements for success in this business, there are unwritten rules and harsh realities.

    Last summer, I painted a room in our house. It took me two months! It was beautiful…perfect. And as the father of a close friend once said, “nice work, but you’ll never make a living at it.” The point being no matter how good the paint job was, I am far too slow a painter to earn a living at it. My time would have been far better spent writing. (which is completely different argument posed by an economist friend of mine: i.e., by not writing, I lost more money than I saved. The same is true in the library game.  No matter how wonderful your music is, if you only produce a few tracks per year, you’ll have a very tough time.

    There’s another, very practical, reason for this as well. A lot of music has a “best when used by” date on it. Things go in cycles. Technology, sounds and tastes change quickly. If you’re only producing a handful of tracks every year AND you’re writing trend driven music, the tracks that you write this year might only replace what you wrote last year, rather than add to it. I wouldn’t want to fill my catalog with 1,000 dubstep cues.

    It’s not that non-prolific writers shouldn’t be in this game. But, they need to have realistic expectations (unless they are working at a very high level).  By analogy, it’s a little like a weekend  warrior trying to compete in the NFL. Every once in a while, it happens. For the majority, though, it will be an avocation.

    _Michael

     

    #7796
    Advice
    Participant

    My understanding is the PROs are still slow to adapt watermarking or fingerprinting, so *right now* the issue is not PROs using technology, it’s what the end users (networks, shows, sups, etc) are willing to accept. They are our customers. Ultimately, if they demand music that is only represented exclusively, that’s the way it will be.

    I have the same tracks in many libraries- something I started years ago before it became an issue. I’ve slowed down this practice quite a bit as I read more and more that down the road I could shoot myself in the foot. If I get a track into a quality library (like an occasional acceptance to that very picky LA library), I won’t put it elsewhere.

    I’d be inclined to say that for tracks in RF libraries whereby the sale depends on end users coming to the site and finding your track, it MIGHT be less risky to be in multiple ones (though you are still competing with yourself and watering down the market). However, with the libraries that market their catalog to music sups via hard disks, catalog website access, etc and may be doing blanket deals, the risk is higher.

    We’ve read on these boards how some end users don’t want to pay for blanket deals with multiple providers only to find the same tracks duplicated– a waste of time and money. Budgets may be too tight to support that. And even in non-blanket situations, all it takes is getting burned once with legal problems over who owns a track to set new policy.

    One thing I’ve observed is many experienced composers who are very prolific will treat every deal as exclusive (e.g. one track/one library). They don’t need to protect every track as one of their “babies”.

    But less prolific folks like myself are much more reluctant to sign exclusives for obvious reasons. Each track holds more importance.

    One could make the argument that if you are not prolific, you shouldn’t be in this game. Not a very nice thing to hear if you only write a handful of tracks per year (like me!), but every industry has qualities one must have to truly succeed.

    I think the most important thing is to make educated choices and understand the POSSIBLE consequences that go along with them. One shouldn’t assume the trend toward all exclusive isn’t real, nor should they panic either.

    😀

    #7794
    Musicmatters
    Participant

    I agree with Tony as well that much depends on the music as to how and where it should be submitted. @Anon, could you explain to me the purpose of pseudonyms, dont you dilute your brand name when you do that, what benefit does it serve ? retitling does have an administrative benefit. Is there a need to be covert about this, therefore the pseudonym ….

    #7792
    Anon
    Guest

    I definitely agree with Tony.


    @Kenny
    – I’ve only done it a small amount so far and can’t say what works best. However if you’re going to do it with only a few libraries I imagine it’s best to use a different name and title at all of them.

    #7788
    Tony
    Guest

    I’m sort of mixed on this. In a way, I think you can devalue your work by blasting it out across the universe. It makes no sense to have a song going out royalty free on several sites if it’s quality work that is current and very likely to earn healthy royalties from placement in higher level libraries. I feel you should save your best work for the better markets and limit the number of  select choice libraries, or go exclusive. On the other hand, old and played-out material, short loops and things of that nature can be sent to every library on earth with no worries.

    Think of it this way. When you’re looking to buy a Rolls Royce, do you go to Cars R Us, eBay, Auto Mart…or a Rolls Royce dealer? Keep in mind that people who can afford a Rolls are never going to shop at the Hoop de Ville Motor Emporium, only people with no money go there. No money means small media projects, no cue sheets, no royalties.

    #7786
    Gus
    Guest

    When I first started I submitted about 20+ songs to about 20 different libraries. I didn’t know anything about them so I wanted to see which ones worked and which ones didn’t. Out of those first 20 libraries, I’m now down to about only 9 that I send music to regularly.

    Out of those nine libraries 3 of them have gone from non-exclusive to exclusive. I’ll still submit the same song to about 3 of these libraries, only cause I know they work with different market, but generally I try to submit one song to one library.

    #7785
    Musicmatters
    Participant

    Thanks for all the responses… the environment has been changing rapidly. Most notably, i have been hearing that ASCAP (my PRO) is pursuing digital fingerprinting, this can create a lot of confusion specially for retitled tracks. The fact that the members of this forum are quite evenly divided means that there is no overwhelming support for either side. I personally see music undergoing a shift from being a service to a commodity and as a result, i feel that at the end of the day the non exclusive model will prevail. I think fingerprinting is the way to go forward, at least then, hopefully we wont have problems of unreported usage of our tracks.

    #7784
    Kenny
    Participant

    @anon

    Do you use a new title and a new pseudonym for each library you submit the song to, or  do  you think it`s enough to use a couple of alternate titles and pseudonyms ?

    #7783
    Anon
    Guest

    Retitle and use pseudonyms…

    #7782
    JD
    Guest

    I personally believe that it is “trial and error”. You won’t know what works best for you and your tracks until you try. “Sprinkle some seeds, and see what grows”. 🙂

Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Get the full picture on every library

Join to see ratings, deal terms and reviews from working composers for 400+ music libraries.

Join now
X

Forgot Password?

Join Us